Features

In praise of book groups

... a new perspective

by Dorothy O'Connor

I have belonged to a book discussion group for over twenty years. It is an
important and valued part of my life. When I try to interest others in joining
such a group, I often get the rejoinder, “Oh, but I  don't want anyone telling
me what to read! I want to make my own choices.”

While I can respect that feeling, I am obliged to point out that being told
“what to read” is, to me, one of the benefits of belonging to the group. Some
of the books I have been required to read are Seabiscuit: An American
Legend
by Laura Hillenbrand; Guns, Germs and Steel by Jared Diamond;
and Winterdance: The Fine Madness of Running the Iditarod by Gary
Paulsen.  

In the case of Seabiscuit, were I left to my own devices, I would never have
selected that book. Horses and horse racing are not part of my world. As I read
Hillenbrand's book, however, I became fascinated with her portrayals of
Seabiscuit's owner, trainer, and jockey, three intriguing men, markedly
different from one another and yet totally dedicated to the care and training
of the horse for eventual stardom on the racetrack.

While reading the book I also learned more about the remarkable author. She
suffers from Chronic Fatigue Syndrome and is seldom able to leave her house.
Her book, written in a style that totally engages the reader is a tribute to
her endurance and her dedication to the craft of writing.

When the group voted to read Jared Diamond's Guns, Germs and Steel I
groaned inwardly, picturing myself laboring through pages and pages of
unfamiliar and uninteresting material. On the contrary, Diamond's well-
researched book is one scholar's answer to the thorny question: why do
countries in the northern hemisphere have more of the world's goods than those
in the southern hemisphere? He draws upon his wide-ranging knowledge in the
disciplines of geography and physiology to amass and synthesize facts. Those
facts are presented in a clear, readable style that holds the reader's
attention.

Several years ago the group embarked on the adventure of reading Gary Paulsen's
Winterdance: The Fine Madness of Running the Iditarod. Just as when I
met up with Seabiscuit, learning about the Iditarod opened up a whole new world
to me. That race, named after a trail used by natives of Alaska, runs from
Anchorage to Nome, a distance of 1150 miles. The first official race was held
in 1973 and it always begins on the first Saturday in March. Gary Paulsen, a
musher with his own team of sixteen dogs, describes his second race in
Winterdance. His first-hand view lends excitement and credibility to the
account as he describes the extraordinary beauty and hardships of the terrain
and the weather. He makes the reader feel the exhaustion and yet the adrenalin
rush of being part of the race.

I set out in this article to show why it is not always a negative to “have” to
read certain books when one is part of a group. I hope I have demonstrated the
other side of the coin.



August 5, 2011



You can search below for any word or words in all issues of the Melrose Mirror.
Loading
| Return to section | The Front Page | Write to us |

Write to us